Dependent T Test
1. **Problem Statement:** We are comparing anxiety levels between students receiving Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) and those receiving No Therapy. We will test if therapy reduces anxiety using a dependent samples t-test.
2. **Step 1: State the hypotheses**
- Null hypothesis ($H_0$): There is no difference in anxiety levels between CBT and No Therapy groups. Formally, $H_0: \mu_D = 0$, where $\mu_D$ is the mean difference.
- Alternative hypothesis ($H_A$): CBT reduces anxiety levels, so anxiety levels differ between groups. For two-tailed test: $H_A: \mu_D \neq 0$ (or one-tailed if expecting reduction).
3. **Step 2: Calculate the differences for each pair**
$$D = CBT - No\ Therapy = [12-35, 17-37, 20-39, 22-33, 29-26, 30-29] = [-23, -20, -19, -11, 3, 1]$$
4. **Step 3: Calculate mean and standard deviation of the differences**
- Mean difference ($\bar{D}$):
$$\bar{D} = \frac{-23 + (-20) + (-19) + (-11) + 3 + 1}{6} = \frac{-69}{6} = -11.5$$
- Calculate squared differences from mean:
$$[(-23+11.5)^2, (-20+11.5)^2, (-19+11.5)^2, (-11+11.5)^2, (3+11.5)^2, (1+11.5)^2] = [-11.5^2, -8.5^2, -7.5^2, 0.5^2, 14.5^2, 12.5^2] = [132.25, 72.25, 56.25, 0.25, 210.25, 156.25]$$
- Sum of squared deviations:
$$\sum = 132.25 + 72.25 + 56.25 + 0.25 + 210.25 + 156.25 = 627.5$$
- Sample standard deviation of differences ($s_D$):
$$s_D = \sqrt{\frac{627.5}{6-1}} = \sqrt{125.5} \approx 11.2$$
5. **Step 4: Calculate the t-value**
Using formula for dependent samples t-test:
$$t = \frac{\bar{D}}{s_D / \sqrt{n}} = \frac{-11.5}{11.2 / \sqrt{6}} = \frac{-11.5}{11.2 / 2.449} = \frac{-11.5}{4.57} \approx -2.52$$
6. **Step 5: Determine degrees of freedom (df)**
$$df = n - 1 = 6 - 1 = 5$$
7. **Step 6: Comment on significance**
- For $\alpha = .05$ and two-tailed test with $df=5$, the critical t-value is about $\pm2.571$.
- Our calculated $t = -2.52$ is slightly less extreme than critical value, so we *fail to reject* the null hypothesis at $\alpha = .05$.
- There is not enough evidence to claim a significant difference in anxiety levels one month after CBT versus no therapy.
8. **Step 7: Assumptions for dependent samples t-test**
- The differences are approximately normally distributed.
- The pairs are dependent/matched correctly.
- The scale of measurement is interval or ratio.
- The observations within pairs are independent of other pairs.
**Final Answer:**
- Calculated t-value: approximately $-2.52$.
- At $\alpha = .05$, result is not statistically significant.
- Assumptions include normality of differences, paired samples, interval scale, and independence between pairs.