Preference Analysis C29038
1. **Problem Statement:**
Given two figures showing Sam's consumption bundles of herbal tea and pancakes, and his preferences, determine which bundles Sam strictly prefers to bundle D based on each figure's information. Also, evaluate the truth of two statements about preferences.
2. **Understanding the "More is Better" Principle:**
Sam always prefers more of either good, holding the other constant.
3. **From Figure 1:**
- Point D is central.
- E has less of both goods than D.
- B, A, F, C have more pancakes but less herbal tea than D.
- G has more herbal tea but less pancakes than D.
- H has more of both goods than D.
Since "more is better," any bundle with more of both goods than D is strictly preferred.
4. **Strict Preference from Figure 1:**
- H has more of both goods than D, so Sam strictly prefers H to D.
- B, A, F, C have more pancakes but less herbal tea, so preference is unclear from Figure 1 alone.
- G has more herbal tea but less pancakes, so preference is unclear.
- E has less of both, so not preferred.
Thus, from Figure 1, only H is strictly preferred to D.
5. **From Figure 2:**
- Indifference curves I1, I2, I3 show levels of utility.
- E and B lie on I1 (lowest utility).
- G, D, A, F lie on I2 (middle utility).
- C lies on I3 (higher utility).
- H lies beyond I3 (highest utility).
Bundles on higher indifference curves are strictly preferred.
6. **Strict Preference from Figure 2:**
- C is on I3, higher than D on I2, so C is strictly preferred.
- H is beyond I3, so strictly preferred.
- E and B on I1 are less preferred.
- G, A, F on I2 are indifferent to D.
7. **Summary Table:**
| Bundle | Figure 1 Strictly Preferred? | Figure 2 Strictly Preferred? |
|--------|------------------------------|------------------------------|
| A | No | No |
| B | No | No |
| C | No | Yes |
| E | No | No |
| F | No | No |
| G | No | No |
| H | Yes | Yes |
8. **Statements:**
- "Figure 1 indicates that Sam prefers bundle C to G."
- From Figure 1, C and G have trade-offs (more pancakes vs more tea), so preference is unclear. **False**.
- "Figure 2 indicates that Sam is indifferent among bundles C and G."
- C is on I3, G on I2, so C is strictly preferred to G. **False**.
**Final answers:**
- Strictly preferred to D given Figure 1: H
- Strictly preferred to D given Figure 2: C, H
- Statement 1: False
- Statement 2: False