Tautology Check D7C20C
1. **State the problem:** Determine if each of the following logical statements is a tautology (always true).
2. **Recall:** A tautology is a formula that is true in every possible interpretation.
3. **Analyze statement (i):** $((\neg P \wedge (P \wedge q)) \to q)$
- Note that $P \wedge q$ is true only if both $P$ and $q$ are true.
- $\neg P \wedge (P \wedge q)$ requires $P$ to be both true and false simultaneously, which is impossible.
- Therefore, the antecedent $\neg P \wedge (P \wedge q)$ is always false.
- An implication with a false antecedent is always true.
- Hence, statement (i) is a tautology.
4. **Analyze statement (ii):** $(((p \to q) \wedge (q \to r)) \to (p \to r))$
- This is the transitivity of implication.
- If $p$ implies $q$ and $q$ implies $r$, then $p$ implies $r$.
- This is a well-known tautology in propositional logic.
- Hence, statement (ii) is a tautology.
5. **Analyze statement (iii):** $((\neg q \wedge (p \to q)) \to \neg p)$
- Suppose $\neg q$ is true and $p \to q$ is true.
- Since $p \to q$ is true and $q$ is false, $p$ must be false (otherwise $p \to q$ would be false).
- Therefore, $\neg p$ is true.
- Hence, the implication holds in all cases.
- Statement (iii) is a tautology.
**Final answers:**
- (i) is a tautology.
- (ii) is a tautology.
- (iii) is a tautology.