Logical Fallacies
1. **Problem (a):** Check if the proposition $$1^3 + 2^3 + 3^3 + \cdots + n^3 = \left[\frac{n(n-1)}{2}\right]^2$$ is true for all positive integers $n$ based on the given argument.
2. The argument tests the formula for $n=1,2,3,4$ and finds the left-hand side (l.h.s.) equals the right-hand side (r.h.s.) in each case.
3. However, the formula given is incorrect. The known correct formula for the sum of cubes is:
$$\sum_{k=1}^n k^3 = \left[\frac{n(n+1)}{2}\right]^2$$
not $$\left[\frac{n(n-1)}{2}\right]^2$$.
4. The mistake is in the formula itself: the argument verifies a wrong formula for some values but does not prove it for all $n$.
5. Testing $n=1$ to $4$ is not sufficient to prove the formula for all positive integers; this is a fallacy called "proof by example".
---
6. **Problem (b):** Solve the simultaneous equations:
$$2C + 3c = 10$$
$$4C - 4c = 0$$
7. The argument claims from the first equation:
$$2C + 3c = 10 \Rightarrow 5c = 10 \Rightarrow c = 2$$
8. This step is incorrect because $2C + 3c = 10$ does not imply $5c=10$ unless $2C=0$, which is not given.
9. The mistake is treating $2C + 3c = 10$ as if $2C$ and $3c$ can be combined into $5c$; this is a fallacy.
10. Therefore, the solution $c=2$, $C=2$ is not correctly derived.
---
11. **Problem (c):** Mulingo claims that $E = f$ (elephant's mass equals fly's mass) based on the following steps:
12. Starting with:
$$(E - f)^2 = [-1]^2 (E - f)^2$$
which is true since $[-1]^2 = 1$.
13. Then:
$$(E - f)^2 = [-1(E - f)]^2 = (f - E)^2$$
14. Taking square roots:
$$\sqrt{(E - f)^2} = \sqrt{(f - E)^2}$$
which gives
$$(E - f) = (f - E)$$
15. This implies:
$$E - f = f - E \Rightarrow 2E = 2f \Rightarrow E = f$$
16. The fallacy is in step 14: the square root of $a^2$ is $|a|$, not $a$.
17. So,
$$\sqrt{(E - f)^2} = |E - f|$$
and
$$\sqrt{(f - E)^2} = |f - E| = |E - f|$$
18. Therefore,
$$|E - f| = |E - f|$$
which is always true but does not imply $E - f = f - E$.
19. The error is ignoring the absolute value and assuming the square root function returns the original expression without sign consideration.
---
**Summary:**
- (a) Fallacy: Incorrect formula and proof by example.
- (b) Fallacy: Incorrect algebraic manipulation.
- (c) Fallacy: Misuse of square root properties ignoring absolute values.